I finally decided to try a moisturizing cleanser called Albolene Moisturizing Cleanser, and I am utterly amazed with this product! I have combination skin, but the area around my eyes is very sensitive. I really don't like all the tugging I do when I take off eye makeup, especially stubborn mascara. In the jar the product resembles Vaseline, but once you scoop up a glob, the heat from your skin liquefies it. I massage it into my skin for a minute or two before removing it with a warm washcloth, and every last bit of makeup, dirt, and mascara is gone. I find Albolene to feel very soothing. It leaves my skin feeling super soft and moisturized, so much so, that I could skip a separate moisturizer if I chose to. The price is quite reasonable as well, around $11.99 for a big tub.
Ingredients: Mineral oil, petrolatum, paraffin, ceresin, beta carotene.
This is one of the best eye and face makeup removers I have tried, and I will be using it regularly now. As you can see, it gets a very BIG thumbs up from me. Albolene is definitely something that I will keep handy in my house!